Make The Perfect DIY Seed-Starting Mix: Easy Recipes For Strong, Healthy Seedlings

Starting your own plants from seed is one of the most rewarding parts of gardening, but success often comes down to the right foundation. A quality seed-starting mix provides the ideal balance of moisture retention, aeration, and essential nutrients to give tender seedlings the best possible start in life.

While store-bought options are widely available, making your own DIY seed-starting mix allows you to control all the ingredients, ensuring its free of harmful chemicals and tailored to your plants' needs. Plus, it's more cost-effective in the long run – especially if you're planting a lot of seeds.

If you're starting seeds indoors, a well-balanced mix is even more important, as indoor conditions are not always optimal. By making your own blend, you can fine-tune the texture and moisture-retentive properties to suit different types of plants, whether you're growing vegetables, herbs, or flowers. Once you have your mix ready, knowing how to germinate seeds properly will further increase your chances of success when planting seeds.

There are many ingredients that can be used to make a DIY seed-staring mix, each with its own benefits. Whether you want something ultra-light for delicate seedlings, or a mix with extra nutrients, you can experiment and adjust based on your experience. Try our suggested recipes, and once you get the hang of it you'll never need to buy an expensive bagged mix again.

Do I Need a Seed-Starting Mix?

What are seeds? Inside every seed is a tiny baby plant called an embryo. This embryo is surrounded by endosperm, a tissue that provides the nourishment it needs to grow. When the seed receives moisture, oxygen, and the right temperature to germinate, the first seed leaves – cotyledons – burst through the seed coat.

To enable this process, the seed has to be supported by a moist growing medium. This can be pretty minimal to start with – you can even germinate seeds in paper towel – but the emerging seedling needs other conditions to fuel its continued growth. These can be found in a good seed-starting mixture.

While you can start seeds in other growing mediums, including soil, they may not provide the best structure or nutrient balance for seedlings.

There are many seed-starting mixes available to purchase but you can also make your own quite easily. The key is to have equal parts of retention, draining, and filling components.

Why Make Your Own Seed-Starting Mix?

Seed-starter mixes are surprisingly expensive, yet the components are not. You can even make some of the ingredients in your own garden. The bonus when making your own mix is that you know exactly what is in it. If you want to use organic products you can source organic. You can check labels and make sure there are no chemical additives.

The standard components are also good amendments that can be used for improving garden soil and potting soil. These materials will keep for quite a while, with the exception of compost and leaf mold, which will continue breaking down. Any leftover components have excellent secondary uses in the garden.

Seed Mixture Materials

To address a seedling's needs of water, nutrients, and oxygen, you will want to plant in a medium that contains these requirements. The below ingredients are all excellent components of a seed-starting mixture.

• Peat Moss
  This lightweight, moisture-retaining material is made from decomposed sphagnum moss. It's ideal for seed starting because it holds water without becoming soggy, provides good aeration, and is sterile so helps avoid disease. However, many gardeners prefer to stay away from peat-based mixtures. This is because peat is a non-renewable resource and harvesting it releases methane and carbon dioxide into the air. Additionally, it takes thousands of years for peat moss to form.
• Rice Hulls
  Hulls are the protective outer shells of rice grains and are a byproduct of commercial rice production. When used in a seed-starting mix, they improve aeration, retain moisture without compacting, and are sustainable and biodegradable.
• Leaf Mold
  Prized by gardeners as a rich, moisture-retentive soil amendment, leaf mold is simply dried fall leaves that are decomposed in a bag. It's beneficial for seed-starting because it improves soil structure, retains water without becoming compacted, and supports beneficial microbes.
• Biochar
  The remnant of burnt organic materials, biochar is a type of charcoal that enhances soil quality. It improves drainage, retains moisture, and supports microbes.
• Coconut Coir
  This fibrous material is from under the coconut shell. It works well as a seed-starting ingredient because it retains moisture while allowing good drainage and resists compaction. It is also naturally resistant to many pests.
• Soil
  In their natural environment, most seeds germinate in soil, so it can certainly be used for seed starting at home. Loamy, nutrient-rich soil provides essential support, moisture retention, and microbes to help seedlings develop strong roots.
• Compost
  While often used as a soil improver, compost can also be used in seed-starting to enhance soil fertility, improve structure, and aid water retention. Learning how to compost at home will keep you in good supply of this essential organic matter.
• Perlite
  A lightweight volcanic mineral, perlite is widely used for improving soil aeration and drainage.
• Vermiculite
  Often used interchangeably or in combination with perlite, vermiculite is a natural mineral that expands when heated, creating a light, moisture-retentive growing medium.
• Sand
  Horticultural sand can be added to aid drainage and prevent soil compaction.
• Worm Castings
  Essentially these are nutrient-rich worm waste. In seed starting, they improve soil fertility, moisture retention, and structure, and introduce beneficial microbes. You can purchase worm castings, but it's easy to produce them at home through vermicomposting.

Seed-Starting Mix Recipes

So what amounts and combinations are best for germinating and growing on seeds? Here are 5 homemade, DIY seed-starting recipes to get you growing.

Basic Three-Part Seed-Starting Mix

Most seed-starter recipes are composed of only three ingredients. The most common recipe combines peat moss, perlite, and vermiculite in equal measure.

Use the same measuring tool for each of the components. Mix everything together well and add water until everything is well moistened. This can take quite a bit of water with the peat moss, as peat can absorb around 25 times its weight in water.

Once everything is combined, the seed-starter mix is ready to use.

Peat-Free Seed-Starting Mix

If you wish to avoid using peat, there are many other materials that will work. Peat moss holds moisture and loosens the soil, but so do many other commonly available organic materials. To make a peat-free seed-starter mix try combining coconut coir, perlite, and vermiculite. If you have worm castings these will add a gentle fertilizer to the mixture.

Simply pour equal parts of the three main ingredients into a large container. Add a handful of the worm castings and mix everything together well.

Prior to planting in this mixture, moisten everything just until it holds shape when you clench some in your hand. You can also combine equal parts of coir, perlite, and compost.

Using Potting Soil to Start Seeds

If all you have is potting soil, you can still use this to start seeds. First, you need to sift it to remove pieces of bark and other large particles that would impede seed germination. The Vego Modular Garden Sifter, available in the Gardening Know How Shop, is ideal for creating fine-grain soil, and includes a removable screen for easy cleaning.

Once you have sifted your soil, it is a good idea to sterilize it to kill any pathogens:

1. Preheat the oven to 200°F (90°C).
2. Pour the soil into shallow trays or cookie sheets.
3. Moisten the soil and cover the containers with foil.
4. Bake the soil for half an hour.

The soil is now sterile, loose, and free of large chunks, making it ready for seed starting. However, the process will have destroyed the beneficial bacteria in the soil. You can give sterilized soil a microbial boost by mixing in worm castings, leaf mold, or biochar – use 9 parts soil to 1 part biochar.

Recipes with Compost

Another very common mix for starting seeds is equal amounts of peat moss, perlite, and compost. Make sure your compost is well decomposed. Freshly made compost from your bin could be too hot for sensitive new roots. The compost should be screened to remove any unfinished items. It should be dark brown and completely broken down.

You can also add a bit of worm castings and a sprinkle of azomite, which is a natural mineral powder that comes from volcanic deposits in Utah. It contains trace minerals good for young plants.

Other combinations using compost are:

• Mix 4 parts of compost with 2 parts each of peat moss, vermiculite, and perlite.
• Mix 2 parts compost with 2 parts coconut coir or leaf mold, and 1 part perlite.
• Mix 1 part compost with 2 parts coconut coir and 1 part rice hulls.

Can I Use Potting Soil to Start Seeds?

You can certainly start seeds in a purchased potting soil. But a soilless seed-starter mix is a very light mixture that allows those tiny roots and shoots to easily move up through the material. Potting soil is denser and contains many more nutrients because it is engineered to grow plants into maturity.

Seed starters are just intended to get the seed coat to crack and the embryo to start growing. Potting soils often have added fertilizer that can burn young seedlings. They are also prone to holding too much moisture and can contain fungi spores that will cause damping off in seedlings.

More Seed-Starting Inspiration

• Struggling to grow successfully? Fix these 7 seed-starting mistakes before it's too late.
• Learn when to start seeds indoors – to ensure bigger harvests and more beautiful flowers.
• Sow these 5 flower seeds before winter ends for the most gorgeous spring blooms.
• Browse seed-starting essentials in the Gardening Know How Shop – from complete growing kits to professional-quality seedling trays and stunning seed collections.

This article features products available from third party vendors on the Gardening Know How Shop.